How many checks error-proof loading needs: before loading, after loading, at changeover
Error-proofing is not one scan but three checks with different purposes. Scanning only after loading still lets changeover and splicing errors through.
Loading error-proofing needs three checks, at kitting completion, at loading completion and at the start of a changeover. Each has a different purpose: the first prevents taking the wrong reel, the second prevents placing it on the wrong feeder, the third prevents splicing wrongly. Do only one and the other two errors still happen.
What each of the three points checks
| Point | Checked object | Purpose | Consequence of failure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Before loading (kitting) | Kitting list against the physical reel | Wrong part, wrong batch, insufficient leftover | Discovered at the line, kitting redone |
| After loading (before first article) | Feeder, part number, substitution | Wrong feeder, reversed reel orientation | Bad first article or a whole batch wrong |
| Changeover and splicing | Old and new reel barcodes, remaining quantity | Wrong part spliced in, mixed batches, leftover overrun | Wrong material mid-run, dozens of boards later when found |
Most plants do only the second. The first relies on the warehouse being careful and the third on the operator being careful, and neither leaves a record, so when something goes wrong there is nobody to check with.
Why the after-loading check is the one most often skipped
The after-loading verification happens before the mounter raises an alarm, and the window is narrow: the line is waiting for the first article and the operator wants to start, so the scan gets skipped. Three common ways:
- One reel is scanned and the rest are assumed from "we picked them together"
- A substitute is scanned as the main part, because scanning the substitute raises an alarm
- At changeover the previous order's scan records are reused
All three leave "scanned" in the system; only the data is untrue. Preventing them depends not on training but on the machine not starting without the scan.
The first article covers the last gap
First-article judgment is the final layer of the loading check, and it looks at physical reality: reference designators, polarity, silkscreen, reel orientation. It cannot replace the scan, because only one board is sampled; and the scan cannot replace it, because the scan compares data and not physical orientation.
The division of labour: the scan ensures that what the system believes matches the BOM; the first article ensures that what was actually placed matches the system. Both together close the loop.
What makes a check record valid
A valid record answers: who, when, at which feeder, which reel was scanned, and what the result was. Miss any one and it does not count in an audit.
Storing only "pass" is not recommended, because pass is the same as nothing: exceptions are the part worth checking. A workable approach records the raw value of every scan, including failed attempts, which exposes a feeder that was scanned repeatedly.
When the number of checks can be reduced
- On single-sided lines with fewer than thirty part numbers, the separate kitting verification can be dropped and merged into loading
- Where the customer requires no traceability, the changeover check can cover only the changed feeders rather than everything
- On lines already at level-3 interception with lit racks in feeder order, guided kitting can replace manual comparison before loading
Reducing checks is legitimate when an earlier step has been fixed in the system, not simply to save time.
Frequently asked questions
FAQ
- Who should do the scan after loading?
- The operator scanning with a team leader countersigning is most common, and most easily skipped. The more reliable approach is enforcement by the system: the machine does not unlock without the scan, which turns "people must remember" into "it cannot be done otherwise".
- Can the first article replace the scan?
- No. The first article samples one board and checks physical orientation and polarity; the scan compares feeder and part-number data. They cover different error types and both are required.
- Should everything be rescanned at a changeover?
- It depends on the changeover. A full model change should be scanned completely; when only some feeders change, scan the changed ones but lock the unchanged ones in the system so nobody has to judge which reels moved.
- How long should records be kept?
- Per customer and system requirements, generally at least the product lifecycle. Automotive electronics customers usually require the full production period plus the after-sales years; the customer's audit checklist is the reference.