Why PCBs are panelised: which of the three methods fits
Panelising keeps the placement machine and reflow oven loaded, uses the panel fully and aligns the reflow direction. V-cut, stamp-hole and bridge methods differ by board thickness, size and depaneling.
Panelisation exists to keep the machines busy: a small board fed straight into the mounter spends too much of the cycle on nozzle travel and transfer, so output stays low; panelised, several boards are placed in one pass and output per unit time rises clearly. Material utilisation and a consistent reflow direction are secondary purposes.
Three purposes, in priority order
- Machine efficiency: the panel size approaches the machine's best transfer width, so placement and transfer balance out
- Material utilisation: fit as many single boards as possible into a standard sheet to reduce waste edge
- Process consistency: one reflow direction across the panel, avoiding thermal stress differences from mixed sides
The three often conflict. The layout with the best utilisation is rarely the size with the best machine efficiency, and efficiency usually wins over utilisation.
Choosing between the three methods
| Method | How | Board thickness | Separation | Limits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| V-cut | A straight groove milled between boards | 0.8 mm and up | V-cut separator | Groove must be straight; complex outlines are impossible |
| Mouse bites | Dense small holes between boards | 0.6 mm and up | Snapping or routing | Holes take routing space and leave burrs |
| Bridges | A few connecting tabs, the rest routed away | 0.6–1.6 mm | Router or snips | Tabs must be strong enough not to break in transit |
Thin boards (below 0.6 mm) tend to crack when V-cut, so mouse bites or bridges are used. Complex outlines can only use bridges, because V-cut requires a straight line.
Deciding the panel count
More is not better. Four constraints apply:
- Machine transfer width: beyond the mounter's maximum, the panel has to shrink
- Reflow uniformity: the larger the panel, the bigger the temperature difference between edge and centre, especially on thick boards
- Separation stress: the denser the layout, the more stress reaches components at separation, and parts near the board edge crack
- Per-board tolerance: tolerances accumulate across the panel and affect placement accuracy
The usual approach is to derive the panel count from the machine's best size and then check whether utilisation is acceptable. Boards smaller than 50 × 50 mm are usually panelised four to eight up; a board above 100 mm at two up is already close to the machine limit.
When not to panelise
- The single board already approaches the machine's maximum width, so a panel will not fit
- Tall components (connectors, shields) at inconsistent heights block reflow when panelised
- Volume is too low to amortise the fixture cost
- The customer requires single-board shipment with no separation marks
What panelisation means for MES
Panelisation turns "one board" into "one panel", and the granularity of traceability changes. The system has to handle two things: the mapping between panel ID and board IDs, and the moment of separation. Otherwise a board can only be traced to its panel, not to a position.
Audits for automotive and medical customers ask about this: can a board after separation be mapped back to its position on the panel before separation. If not, defects on other boards of the same panel cannot be related.
Frequently asked questions
FAQ
- Does a higher panel count always reduce cost?
- No. The count is limited by the machine's maximum board width, the temperature spread in the reflow oven and separation stress. Beyond the best size the cycle stops improving while separation defects and placement tolerance get worse.
- Can a 0.6 mm board be V-cut?
- Not recommended. The remaining thickness at a V-cut on a thin board is too small and it cracks or delaminates at separation. Thin boards usually use mouse bites or bridges, with routing and a fixture.
- Mouse bites or bridges?
- It depends on edge space and separation method. Tight edges routed by machine favour bridges; spare edge that can be snapped favours mouse bites. Bridge strength depends heavily on tab width design.
- Does panelisation affect traceability?
- Yes. After panelisation the mapping between panel ID and board IDs has to be built, and the separation moment recorded. Otherwise a board can only be traced to its panel and defects on the other boards of that panel cannot be related.